10 Best Drugstore Eyeliners Reviews in 2021 Review & Guide

In a woman’s makeup bag, Eyeliner happens to be a prominent piece of equipment, and for all the right reasons!

Any makeup look is going to look incomplete without the delicate touch of Eyeliner.

But, if you are looking to choose the best Drugstore eyeliner, the search will not be easy.

There are many drugstore eyeliners present on the market, which makes it difficult thing for a person to come up with the best drugstore eyeliner.

However, in order to help you choose the best drugstore eyeliner for you, we have put together a list of the ten best drugstore eyeliners present on the market right now.

In a hurry? Here is a list of all the products discussed in detail below:

 ProductDetailsShop
INSL-X WR102309A

Maybelline Master Precise Eyeliner

  • Brand: Maybelline New York
  • Item Form: Liquid
  • Item Weight: 0.02 Pounds
Buy Now
INSL-X WR102309A

Revlon Colorstay Liquid Eye Pen

  • Brand: REVLON
  • Color: Black
  • Item Weight: 0.56 Ounces
Buy Now
INSL-X WR102309A

Milani Eye Tech Extreme Liquid Eyeliner

  • Brand: Milani
  • Item Weight: 0.08 Pounds
  • Item Dimensions LxWxH: 6 x 8 x 2 inches
Buy Now
INSL-X WR102309A

Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner

  • Brand: COVERGIRL
  • Color: Pitch Black Passion 800
  • Item Weight: 0.03 Pounds
Buy Now
INSL-X WR102309A

L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Liner

  • Brand: L'Oreal Paris
  • Item Form: Pencil, Gel
  • Color: Blackest Black
Buy Now
INSL-X WR102309A

NYX Professional Makeup

  • Brand: NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP
  • Color: Extreme Black
  • Item Weight: 0.05 Pounds
Buy Now
INSL-X WR102309A

e.l.f Expert Liquid Eyeliner

  • Color: Jet Black
  • Item Form: Liquid
  • Brand: E.l.f.
Buy Now
INSL-X WR102309A

Rimmel Exaggerate Felt Tip Liquid Eyeliner

  • Brand:Rimmel
  • Item Form:Liquid
  • Color:Black
Buy Now
INSL-X WR102309A

Almay Liquid Eyeliner

  • Brand:Almay
  • Coverage:Eyes
  • Color:Black
Buy Now
INSL-X WR102309A

NYC High Definition Liquid Eyeliner

  • Brand:NYC
  • Item Weight:0.02 Pounds
  • Color:Extra Black
Buy Now

Best Drugstore Eyeliners Review:

1. Maybelline Master Precise Eyeliner

Maybelline Master Precise Eyeliner

Features:

  • Waterproof. 
  • Highly Pigmented. 
  • This Drugstore eyeliner is precise and anti-smudge.

To begin our list, we would like to present the option that we think is the best drugstore eyeliner overall;

Coming with many remarkable features, such as being waterproof, this product happens to be one of the best options on the list.

Besides the fact that this product happens to be waterproof, this best drugstore eyeliner mounts an ultra-fine tip.

This tip does its job by offering exact applications.

Moreover, this product also happens to be long-wearing and smudge-proof as well.

Due to these qualities, this best drugstore eyeliner delivers the most accurate definition to the eye in just a single stroke.

PROS

  • This Manufacturer has designed this product to make the application process relatively easy and simplistic. 
  • This best drugstore eyeliner comes with mounted features such as smudge-proof and waterproofing, making it last longer than any other option. 
  • This best drugstore eyeliner is highly pigmented.
  • Due to this, the application process is smooth.

CONS

  • None.

2. Revlon Colorstay Liquid Eye Pen

Revlon Colorstay Liquid Eye Pen

Features:

  • The packaging of this product is Pen Packaging. 
  • The Viscosity of this product is just right. 
  • The Application process of this best drugstore eyeliner is straightforward.

This best drugstore eyeliner from Revlon also goes by the name of “Blackest Black.”

This eyeliner gets the other name for being highly pigmented, which makes it offer unique details to the user’s eyes.

Before we get started on the product quality of this best drugstore eyeliner, we would like to mention that this product comes in pen packaging.

Due to the pen packaging, the application process of this drugstore eyeliner is relatively easy.

Since this best drugstore eyeliner is not too thick or too runny either, the application process of this product is rather simplistic.

Since it is not too runny, this product can easily stay put for about 11-12 hours after application.

This product is going to be an excellent choice for anyone.

However, this product happens to be the best drugstore eyeliner for you if you have oily eyelids.

PROS

  • Since this product is highly pigmented, this eyeliner offers great details upon application. 
  • The felt tip of this best drugstore eyeliner is tapered. 
  • The application process of this eyeliner does not create any mess.

CONS

  • This Eyeliner is not waterproof.

3. Milani Eye Tech Extreme Liquid Eyeliner

Milani Eye Tech Extreme Liquid Eyeliner

Features:

  • This eyeliner allows the users to have three different lines. 
  • This eyeliner happens to be waterproof. 
  • The application process of this Eyeliner is relatively simple.

If you want something that can offer you various application methods, this is the best drugstore eyeliner for you!

With this Party-proof eyeliner, the users will create a thin, medium, or thick line.

All they will have to do is switch the angle they will be holding the eyeliner at.

Moreover, this best drugstore eyeliner comes in a pen-style format.

The design of this best eyeliner happens to be sleek.

Due to its elegant design, the application process of this drugstore eyeliner is pretty simple and easy.

In conclusion, If you want to try out various applications without having to spend a lot of money, this is the best drugstore eyeliner that you can buy.

PROS

  • This best drugstore eyeliner comes with an ultra-fine tip. 
  • Since this product is made from some of the best items, this product happens to be long-lasting. 
  • When applying, this product has a smooth flow.

CONS

  • The tip of this Drugstore eyeliner is slightly stiff as compared to the other options.

4. Covergirl Perfect Point Plus Eyeliner

Features:

  • The application process of this product is pretty simple. 
  • This best drugstore eyeliner has a feature that self-sharpens the tip for smooth application.

This product happens to be a fantastic option due to its many features.

However, one thing that is truly outstanding about this best drugstore eyeliner is that this best drugstore eyeliner can offer up to 8 shades.

Moreover, after choosing the right shade for application, the users can later smudge out the line using the soft smudger tip that comes along.

This product, furthermore, also boasts a specifically designed tip. This tip sharpens by itself.

Due to this tip, the product can make sure that the users can draw the perfect lines every time they use it.

This eyeliner comes with a soft smudger tip.

PROS

  • This product happens to be Ophthalmologist-tested. 
  • The formula of this best drugstore eyeliner is relatively smooth. 
  • This drugstore eyeliner does not tug or exert any pull on the eyelid.

CONS

  • This Drugstore eyeliner is difficult to remove.

5. L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Liner Noir Liquid Eyeliner Pen

L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Liner Noir Liquid Eyeliner Pen

Features:

  • This Drugstore eyeliner happens to be highly pigmented. 
  • The design of this eyeliner accounts for a smooth application. 
  • Due to its design and high-quality materials, this product glides on smoothly.

L’Oreal happens to be one of the best choices when it comes to beauty products.

Coming from them, we can’t expect anything less from this product!

Among so many reasons that this product happens to be the best one, what makes this the best drugstore eyeliner is its affordability.

This product happens to be highly affordable and also happens to be of premium quality.

This product comes in a marker-like design.

Due to this design, the users can gain control over how thick the line of the product flows.

To conclude, if you are searching for a smooth application, this is the best drugstore eyeliner for you!

PROS

  • This best drugstore eyeliner features a fine tip. 
  • Rubbing off this drugstore eyeliner is not going to be easy. 
  • This best drugstore eyeliner happens to be one of the most affordable options.

CONS

  • On hot days, this Drugstore eyeliner appears to be a little smudgy.

6. NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner

NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner

Features:

  • This product features a precise tip. 
  • This eyeliner happens to be waterproof. 
  • Since this product is highly pigmented, it can help your eyes have a surprising look.

As it happens, the Cat-eye liner look happens to be the hardest to achieve.

If you want to have a perfect cat-eye liner look, then this is the best drugstore eyeliner for the job.

Due to its highly accurate tip, this product can draw a cat-eye liner smoothly and flexibly.

However, that’s not even the best part!

The tip of this product is so precise and Pigmented that it can help you achieve any look you want with only a single stroke!

Other than the highly precise tip, the fluid formula of this product also happens to be a stand-out feature.

Due to its formula, this product happens to be very easy to apply.

To conclude, if you want to pull off challenging and unique looks, then this is the best drugstore eyeliner for the job.

PROS

  • This best drugstore eyeliner offers a matte finish when applied. 
  • This product is made from cruelty-free materials. 
  • This best drugstore eyeliner happens to be vegan.

CONS

  • None.

7. e.l.f Expert Liquid Eyeliner

Features:

  • This Liquid Eyeliner has Good pigmentation. 
  • This Eyeliner is compatible with other makeup products. 
  • This Drugstore eyeliner does not take very long to dry.

Tugging and pulling happens to be a consistent problem when it comes to drugstore eyeliner.

But with this eyeliner, these issues are the issues of the past!

We like to think of this product as the best drugstore eyeliner for this very reason.

What makes this product one of the best is the fact that this product does not boast any fancy packaging.

This product comes in traditional bottle packaging.

Due to this packaging, the application process is pretty straightforward.

Since this product is highly pigmented, the users can have a good satin finish only by applying a single stroke of this product.

To conclude, if you want something that is easy to apply at a meager price tag, then this is the best drugstore eyeliner for you.

PROS

  • The application process of this eyeliner happens to be simple. 
  • This product is available in five different shades. 
  • This drugstore eyeliner happens to be waterproof as well as anti-smudge.

CONS

  • The quantity of this product is less.

8. Rimmel Exaggerate Felt Tip Liquid Eyeliner

Features:

  • This Drugstore eyeliner happens to be Run-proof. 
  • Since this product is flake-proof, the users can be assured that it will not cause any spill. 
  • This product happens to be smudge-proof.

If you are looking to achieve a luxurious and bold look, then this best drugstore eyeliner is the one for you!

This product has many features that make it the best drugstore eyeliner.

In a long list of features, this product happens run-proof, flake-proof, and smudge-proof.

Other than that, this product also offers a matter finish which looks somewhat classy!

Furthermore, this product also happens to be an excellent choice for use with sensitive eyes.

To clarify, this product is going to be the best option for people that wear contact lenses.

All in all, if you want your eyes to offer a beautiful look, then this product happens to be the best option for you.

PROS

  • One of the most affordable options on the list. 
  • The design of this best drugstore eyeliner enhances portability.
  • This Drugstore eyeliner happens to be one of the most enduring options.

CONS

  • This Eyeliner dries off very quickly.

9. Almay Liquid Eyeliner

Almay Liquid Eyeliner

Features:

  • This Eyeliner does not include any preservatives or chemicals.
  • Due to the items used, this product happens to be an excellent choice for people with oily eyelids.
  • The Product is highly pigmented.

This product makes the list for how creamy and buttery it is.

Considering how friendly it is to use, it can be regarded as one of the best drugstore eyeliner options on the list!

To further clarify, this product happens to be the perfect option for people that have oily eyelids or le that live in Humid climates.

What makes it the ideal choice for the mentioned people is its smudge-proof formula.

The formula of this best drugstore eyeliner happens to be highly pigmented.

Due to being highly pigmented, this eyeliner can sit well only within a single stroke.

In conclusion, if you want the best matte finish, this is the one for you. 

PROS

  • This product comes with sturdy packaging.
  • This Best Drugstore eyeliner lasts for more than 12 hours.
  • This eyeliner happens to be smudge-proof.

CONS

  • This eyeliner is difficult to remove after application.

10. NYC High Definition Liquid Eyeliner

NYC High Definition Liquid Eyeliner

Features:

  • This product offers radiant colors. 
  • This eyeliner features a flexible tip that accounts for precise application. 
  • This best drugstore eyeliner happens to be smudge-proof.

Last but not least, this is the best drugstore eyeliner if you are aiming to achieve fresh colors on each application.

Coming with so many long lists of features, this product makes for a great choice.

One of the things that we like about this product the most is its flexible tip.

This flexible tip applicator accounts for a mistake-free application.

Moreover, other features such as water resistance add to how unique this product is.

However, this product happens to be our favorite for the control that it gives to the users when they are going for something extra. 

All in all, this happens to be the best drugstore eyeliner if you want fresh colors with easy application.

PROS

  • If you wear a Contact lens, then this is the perfect choice for you. 
  • Using this product can give off a rich matte color. 
  • Since it is made from the best material, this Eyeliner dries quickly.

CONS

  • This drugstore eyeliner is not a good choice for people that have oily eyelids.

How to Choose the Best Drugstore Eyeliners? – A Buyer’s Guide:Best Drugstore Eyeliners

When it comes to choosing the best drugstore eyeliner, there are some things that you must know about.

Knowing about such things is essential as your decision will depend on it.

If you don’t bring these factors into consideration, then it is highly possible that you may end up buying something that you didn’t want in the first place.

Nonetheless, Here is what you must be on the lookout for when it comes to choosing the best Drugstore Eyeliner for you. 

The Type of the Eyeliner:

When it comes to choosing the best drugstore eyeliners, you must know that the eyeliners come in different kinds.

Knowing this is the first and the most essential step in order to choose the best drugstore eyeliner.

Below are some types of eyeliner!

All of these eyeliners are good for a specific purpose:

  • The Gel Drugstore Eyeliners happens to be an excellent choice for people that are after cat-eye or winged looks.
  • They are able to achieve these looks as they are creamy and thick. 
  • Due to these properties, Gel Liners work consistently with a brush.
  • Similarly, Liquid Eyeliner happens to be a better choice for people that want to achieve precise and sleek lines.
  • If you pair Liquid Eyeliner with a felt-tip applicator, you will gain more control, and you will be able to draw out any look without making things too messy.
  • Last but not least,  a pencil liner is a perfect option if you are aiming to have smokey eyes.
  • Also, if you are a beginner, you will be better off with a pencil liner.
  • However, when it comes to sharpening it, it can get a little troublesome.
  • But, we wouldn’t be wrong to say that its smoothness and the ability to perfectly smudge more than makes up for the lackings.

Frequently Asked Questions:

What are the best drugstore eyeliners?

When it comes to choosing the best drugstore eyeliner, it is easy to get overwhelmed due to the many options available on the market.

However, if you want to choose the best drugstore eyeliner, you must take a look at the buyer’s guide section.

The buyer’s guide section highlights all there is to know about the aspects that make a product the best one.

What is the best eyeliner to use that stays on all day?

The reason behind eyeliners that stay on all day after the application is because it is highly padded.

The more padded a drugstore eyeliner is, the longer it will stay on for after the application.

To choose the eyeliner that stays on all day long, consider how padded it is.

What color eyeliner should an older woman wear?

While most of the options on the market are usually black, the choice depends on you.

You have to make sure that you know which color suits you the best. 

Which Maybelline eyeliner is the best?

A: According to Maybelline, their Eyestudio Hyper Easy Liquid Eyeliner happens to be the best option on the market that is produced by them.

However, if it doesn’t work for you, Maybelline has also called Master Precise All Day Liquid Eyeliner is one of their best options that they have manufactured.

Conclusion!

Here goes our review of the best drugstore eyeliners that you can buy right now.

These happen to be some of the best options on the market, considering the materials that go into it.

However, in order to make a well-informed decision, make sure to go through the buyer’s guide section of this article.

We hope that you are able to choose the best drugstore eyeliner for you from the options mentioned above.